| |
A Decent World Order Cannot
Come from Disorder:
The Elements of Global
Order and Disorder
Glen
T. Martin
Presentation at the
12th International Conference of Chief Justices
of the World, 10
December 2011
If the ‘I’ negates
disorder, that very I, which is separate, will
create another
form of
disorder….that is, I see disorder in myself:
anger,
jealousy, brutality,
violence, suspicion, guilt….
The mind is totally
aware of all this disorder.
Can it completely
negate it, put it away?
Jiddu Krishnamurti
You Are The
World, 1972, pp. 106-7
This statement by
one of the world’s great spiritual teachers also
applies at the level of human political affairs.
If you see disorder in the world, and you see
that it derives from false premises, you cannot
reform the disorder. You must simply negate it,
put it away. One cannot create a civilized and
humane social order from false premises, which
imply disorder. The false premises of the
present world logically imply disorder and
empirically result in massive planetary
disorder.
Planetary political
affairs must begin with true premises, which
imply order. By ‘political affairs,’ I mean the
principles by which we govern ourselves and
organize our social, economic and civilizational
relationships. The principles of political life
are the first principles from which all order
and civilized human relationships derive. Order
derives from true premises. Disorder cannot be
reformed. It must simply be negated so that a
founded global society can take its place.
The principles of
human political affairs (civilization) are quite
simple and function as a ‘natural law’ for human
life. Every rational, clearly thinking person
recognizes them in one form or another. These
principles can be expressed and enumerated in
different ways. In this essay I will discuss
them as five most basic principles for human
civilizational and political affairs. They are
(1) universality, (2) unity in diversity, (3)
individual flourishing, (4) reason and love, and
(5) a community of dialogue directed toward
mutual understanding .
The first of these
principles is universality. Human dignity,
rights, and responsibilities belong to all human
beings without exception. Such universality has
never been realized in human affairs even though
it has been recognized by the most ancient texts
and philosophical schools such as the Stoics of
ancient Greece and Rome. It is a principle that
became central to 20th century
thought as expressed, for example, in the UN
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and in
Articles 12 and 13 of the Constitution for
the Federation of Earth .
In the early 21st century,
we are long past the time when this universal
has become an absolute necessity for the
survival of humanity. Human dignity, rights, and
responsibilities must become foundational in
human affairs.
Yet our primary
planetary institutions operate in direct
violation of these principles. Both the global
economic system and the system of sovereign
nation-states violate the universality of human
rights and dignity. The economic system operates
as if economics were a set of inviolable
quasi-scientific laws (supply and demand, "free
market," etc.) , with
the result that two billion of the Earth’s
population live on less than two US dollars per
day. Their human rights and dignity are violated
by this system of division and fragmentation
that ignores their humanity by making possible
economic theft, systemic exploitation,
commodification (turning human beings into
market commodities), and consequent
dehumanization.
Similarly, the
system of sovereign nation-states divides the
planet into approximately 193 independent
territories recognizing no constitution and no
enforceable laws above themselves. All so-called
"international laws" are merely voluntary
treaties on the part of these sovereign nations.
Since they are voluntary, nations can withdraw,
ignore, or withhold assent to any particular
international agreement. In practice, under such
a system the stronger dominate and exploit the
weaker. Small or weaker nations are coerced into
accepting ‘laws,’ including trade and monetary
rules, imposed by the powerful nations and their
financial institutions. Universality, the
principle that human rights and dignity be
applied systematically throughout civilization ,
is systematically violated by this system of
fragmentation.
There can be no
true civilizational universality to human rights
and dignity without a Constitution for the
Federation of Earth that embodies this
universality and translates it into enforceable
world law. The principle of national sovereignty
fragments the world into incommensurable
territorial units, most of them militarized, in
response this condition of a lawless
international world disorder. From the principle
that nations recognize no law above themselves
(disorder) you cannot derive the universal
recognition of human rights and dignity (order).
You can only derive more disorder .
But seeing the horror and destructive nature of
disorder (perpetual wars, destruction,
dehumanization, deception, and exploitation),
one can simply negate that disorder, put it
aside. Our obligation is to found
planetary systems of universal validity, for
example, by recognizing the authority of the
Earth Constitution from which civilization
can derive all valid universal laws protecting
the rights and dignity of every person on Earth.
The second
principle of order is the principle of unity in
diversity . For
all phenomena within the universe, science has
shown that the diverse parts of reality cohere
with one another within systems that unite them
into unities. Unity in diversity constitutes the
structure of the universe and operates on a
multiplicity of levels composed of parts within
wholes that are in turn parts within
ever-greater wholes. Human beings form one level
of unity in diversity within this vast scheme.
Our unity is that we are all human. Our
diversity is that each person is a unique
individual. Our humanity and individuality form
an inseparable whole.
Sound political
principles are founded on unity in diversity.
These principles must be universal to all human
beings since the unity that unites us is
precisely our common humanity. Under global
capitalism this unity is broken through vast
mechanisms of exploitation where people are
dehumanized and alienated from their common
humanity. The profits for a few are extracted
from the cheap and dehumanized labor of the many
who are being used as tools for production or
services for the few.
Under the disorder
of sovereign nation-states, the world is
fragmented into competing territories violating
the fundamental principle of political order
that all be united by a common constitution that
recognizes and protects the great diversity of
persons and groups. Persons outside of each
nation have no rights or freedoms according to
the laws of the nation, for laws only apply
internally. From the disorder of capitalism and
sovereign nations, order can never follow. Only
by ratification of the Earth Constitution
can we negate the disorder and affirm the
orderly starting point of universal unity in
diversity.
The third
fundamental principle of human and
civilizational affairs is the principle of
individual human flourishing. The purpose of
law and the function of legitimate
constitutional government is to promote
individual human flourishing. The right to the
conditions that make flourishing possible
belongs to each human being. Flourishing means
that I have readily available opportunities for
satisfying my physical needs for nourishing
food, fresh water, sanitary conditions, shelter,
clothing , social
security in case of illness or old age, and
other vital necessities. It means that I have
easily available possibilities for education,
and for availing myself of the fruits of human
knowledge and culture. It also means that my
flourishing in these respects takes place within
a framework of peace, social justice, and a
decent, healthy planetary environment.
The famous formula
of utility cannot give us the principle of
individual human flourishing. The idea of
promoting the greatest happiness of the greatest
number of people fails in a number of ways,
including the issue of means and ends. The idea
of utility does not give us universality. We are
not speaking of the greatest happiness of the
greatest number but of the right of each person
to live within conditions that promote his or
her flourishing.
Individual human
flourishing needs to be the principle of both
means and ends, for it is the individual human
being alone that has dignity and universal
rights. No human as an end in himself or herself
may be used as a means for the happiness of
others, whether this be workers exploited for
the happiness of capitalists or presently living
persons sacrificed for a greater happiness of
future generations.
Under capitalism
individual human flourishing for vast numbers is
destroyed by the process of supply and demand
treating human beings as commodities to be used
in the service of private profit. Under the
nation-state system, the individual human
flourishing of those outside the territorial
boundaries is of no concern to national
governments. Foreign policies conducted in
national self-interest (inevitable within this
system of fragmentation) invariably violate
individual human flourishing for those outside
these boundaries, and (because military
expenditures deplete internal resources and
destroy democratic openness) for citizens within
nations as well. The only way to establish
legitimate government directed toward providing
the framework for individual human flourishing
is to establish a world constitution that
supersedes the global institutions that now
impede universal individual flourishing for all
persons on Earth.
The fourth
principle of global political affairs includes
the right and duty to develop our reason and our
love . This is
related to the above three principles and an
extension of them. The core of individual human
flourishing involves the development of our
reason and our love. As philosopher and
psychoanalyst Erich Fromm has shown, reason and
love, our two highest human qualities, should be
holistically integrated within every human
being. The a priori framework of legally
articulated social and economic conditions
provided by government at all levels, from local
to planetary, must maximize the possibilities
for the development of reason and love in the
citizens. This principle that the function of
good government is to make possible this
development of ‘virtue’ or ‘human excellence’ in
citizens was first elaborated in western
political thought by Aristotle, some 2400 years
ago.
Aristotle saw that
the defining characteristic of the human animal
was rationality and that the development of
excellence also included informing our emotions
and desires with this rational principle .
He focused on friendship as a highest form of
love in human relationships. In this same
period, Plato developed this inseparable
complement of reason as ‘love’ (eros). A
human being is a synthesis of these two
principles. His Symposium articulated the
role of love as a sublimation and shaping of
desire to become the indispensible ally of
reason.
Four centuries later,
Jesus Christ expressed the fundamental role of
love in terms of caring for others, compassion,
and deep respect for all, even ‘for the least of
these my brethren’ (agapé). In truth love
is properly a combination of both desire and
compassion and secures our right relationship to
the world, its creatures, and other persons.
Love is our solidarity with human beings and all
of life. It binds people together in
friendships, families, communities, and the
human community.
Reason, the
complement of love, sees the universality of the
human community that love binds together. Reason
sees the self-evident truth of the natural law
principles articulated in this essay and acts to
secure these principles in human political,
economic, and social affairs. Love empowers
reason in this task. Without love, reason can
become heartless social engineering. Without
reason, love can become self-indulgent and
ineffective sentimentality. Love supplies energy
and its universally affirmative character. It
lifts reason to its highest potentialities.
Reason here is not
merely instrumental or technical reason
calculating how to achieve ends that arise from
irrational, blind desires. Such an idea is a
modern perversion of the profound tradition of
reason in western thought. Reason, rather,
understands the moral dimension and the primary
ends of human life, ends that are also
comprehended intuitively by the love that binds
us together with the world, other creatures, and
the human community.
Love is a principle
of order just as much as reason, for love is the
foundation of the relationships that bind us
into families, communities, and the human
continuum. Love also binds us to our wonderful
planetary home and the ultimate cosmic miracle
of the universe within which we live our lives.
The conception of blind, heartless economic
‘laws’ promoted by global capitalism is not only
untrue, but it is a principle of disorder than
cannot be reformed or evolved into an order
premised on love, which means a world of peace,
justice, and human flourishing. This disorder
must be negated by our reason and our love ,
and a global social democracy must be founded
premised on the priority of human dignity and
human rights within economic relationships.
The same is true of
the system of sovereign nation-states. This
‘system’ is no system ,
for it is an institutionalized disorder dividing
humankind into 193 incommensurate entities
without any binding principles of law or justice
above themselves. One cannot evolve this system
while retaining the principle of national
sovereignty which is the essential component of
this disorder. One must negate the disorder and
establish an order founded on genuine
principles, summarized by the five basic
concepts articulated in this essay. Sovereignty
must be replaced by a global social contract
founded on the human community itself. This
means the ratification of a Constitution for
the Federation of Earth that establishes
universal order, based on reason and love, in
human political affairs for the first time in
history.
The final principle
in universal human political affairs is a
community of dialogue directed toward mutual
understanding .
Such a community of dialogue must be
institutionalized within the universal laws of
under the Earth Constitution. The moral
imperative for dialogue directed toward mutual
understanding (as opposed to strategic or
manipulative uses of speech) has been shown by
Jürgen Habermas and others to be fundamental to
language itself and hence to being human.
Political life under laws characterized by
universality, unity in diversity, human
flourishing, and reason and love must also be
structured to make communicative speech
possible. The World Parliament created by the
Earth Constitution transcends political
struggle among self-interested parties through
structuring speech to optimize the possibility
for dialogue directed toward genuine
understanding and communication.
Under the global
capitalist system of disorder, speech is
pressured to become commercial or manipulative
speech directed toward maximizing self-interest.
Under the nation-state system of international
disorder, speech is institutionalized to be the
speech of deceptive diplomacy, veiled threat,
and strategic maneuvering on behalf of perceived
national self-interests. Nowhere is
communicative dialogue encouraged because the
disorder of these global institutions leads to
the disorder of dishonest speech.
Communicative
dialogue directed toward mutual understanding
among equals is a fundamental principle of order
interrelated with the other four principles
expressed in this essay. Communicative dialogue
invites (and assumes) universality. It invites
(and assumes) unity and diversity. It invites
(and assumes) human flourishing, reasoning, and
love, just as these principles in turn invite
and assume communicative dialogue.
Order cannot come
from disorder. True conclusions cannot derive
from false premises. The false premises of
global capitalism and so-called ‘sovereign’
nation-states cannot provide the basis for an
evolution of truth with regard to the human
condition or human political affairs. The
disorder must be abandoned, simply dropped. In
its place there must be a founded society,
established on the five principles discussed
here. In place of the disorder of the current
world anti-system, we must make a paradigm-shift
to the principles of order and truth. We need a
world that is premised (founded through a
founding ratification convention) on
universality, unity in diversity, human
flourishing, reason and love, and communicative
dialogue. We need to ratify the Constitution
for the Federation of Earth.
To World
Government Article Directory
Back to Home Page
|
|