The Blair Witch Project Meets Survivor in MTV's Fear
Graphic By: Jenn Peterson

Last summer, The Blair Witch Project opened in theaters and was a massive success. As all of you know, the movie was supposed to have been footage of an ill-fated expedition by a trio of young film makers into the woods of Maryland. You were supposed to believe that it was real, but, of course, it wasn't. The movie, loved by few and loathed by many, was a resounding success.

This past summer, CBS unveiled Survivor, a game show unlike any other on TV at the time. Taking real people and putting them into an environment where they must learn to fend for themselves, the show was a smash hit. Millions of people tuned in week after week to see the island inhabitants' fun-loving antics.

So it was only a matter of time before someone got the bright idea of putting the two together. I give you MTV's Fear. The premise of the show is this: six young, photogenic people are placed into a supposedly "haunted" environment, which changes with each episode. They must spend two nights there, completing a series of "dares," or tasks which must be completed before they can leave. The contestants are given a variety of equipment to complete their tasks with: hand-held cameras, night vision goggles, sound equipment, electro-magnetic and infrared sensors. These junior-league Ghostbusters have the option of leaving if it becomes too much for them, but, if they do, they forfeit the prize money: three thousand dollars.

Of course, you're supposed to believe that all of this is real, the producers even flash up a message at the beginning telling you so. Yet this show is so fake, and you can tell that these "contestants" are actually actors. Throughout the pilot episode, "Derek," one of the participants, kept going off on these philosophical tangents about the nature of fear. They obviously sounded scripted, and his delivery was so wooden that I would have wound up laughing in his face if I had been one of the contestants.

The producers want to you be afraid, and they want you to fear for these brave, intrepid souls. Yet throughout most of the program, I found myself either laughing myself stupid or just wanting to jump in the screen and throttle somebody. For this particular episode, the contestants had to spend two nights in the abandoned West Virginia State Penitentiary, supposedly one of the most haunted places in America. One cast member, "Aaron," was charged with going into the electrocution chamber and removing the tarp off of the chair. It was supposed to be suspenseful, yet it came across as quite humorous. Apparently the other team members thought so too; they couldn't contain themselves. Then there was "Lauren," a young woman who practiced witchcraft and called herself "open" to the spirit world. After five minutes into her "dare," she folded like a lawn chair. "Oh God, I want to go home," she sobbed in the prison, in a scene that reminded me way too much of Heather Donahue's final monologue in The Blair Witch Project.

Then there were parts of this show that were just plain cheesy, the character's dialogue aside. The final dare of the program called for Derek to go into the electrocution chamber, sit in silence for fifteen minutes and use his equipment to investigate any paranormal activity. Of course, there was an infrared camera rigged in the room to record Derek sitting there (on the other end of which was probably a team of cameramen, the director, producers, grips, boom mike operators and Wink Martindale with a check to give to Derek to go back to school to take acting lessons). Fifteen minutes pass, and Derek successfully completes the dare. The other team members, who were waiting outside for him, inform him over the walkie-talkie that he can come out now. They hear nothing and try contacting him again. Again nothing. The camera in the electrocution room, where Derek was sitting, shows nothing. Concerned for him, the team sets off to look for him. Just as soon as they get outside, guess who comes running up? Yup, Derek. He took off without telling anyone, just to play a joke on his team members. Now you may insert groan here. Honestly, if anything bad had happened to Derek, do you think MTV would have showed it? They would have been so up to their neck in insurance claims and lawsuits it wouldn't have been funny.

After all was said and done and the prize money was awarded, we were treated to even more cheesy philosophical ruminations on the nature of fear. By this point in the program I had lost complete interest. It's a safe bet I won't be tuning in next week.

The actual concept of this show isn't half bad, but the problem with it is that it tries to take something so fake and pass it off as real. You were supposed to think that The Blair Witch Project was real, but the producers and stars had no trouble telling you it wasn't. Now if the producers of Fear would only do the same, and get some better actors next time, then I might be able to swallow this show. Until then...


Responses:
Refresh frame to view latest entries.


Name: SomeOne
Comments:
Shaun, Funny thing is, the people on the show are real. So all your comments about bad acting and dialog... oh, well, can't please everyone. Also, please check the facts of your article against the show's episode. You got alot wrong. For starters, there's no "Aaron", and Lauren doesn't do witch craft.

Name: lauren
Year: 200
Major: middle school
Comments:
if u would have been there you would have known...lauren

Name: Rad Woman
Year: Senior
Comments:
I've only seen one episode, the one that Shaun referred to ofen in his article. Now, I may just be one of those cheesy people that the producers of these kind of shows love, because I fell for it totally. Personally I get scared just walking around my apartment in the dark (the complex was built inside an old church) I can't imagine being inside one of the most haunted prisons in America in the dark. And Blair Witch scared the crap out of me. It took me a week to get Heather's scream from the end of the movie out of my head. And I even knew it was fake before I went to it. And again, I was a die hard Survivor fan, too! I know it may seem like I'm just hopping on the bandwagon here, but I'm a media studies minor, I've studied this stuff, and it's ingenious. And our generation is totally eating it up. Including me. You may have been laughing, Shaun, while I was getting spooked, but either way, we both were entertained!

Name: The Shape
Comments:
I actually enjoy this show. I believe in the paranormal and the occult, even researched it a bit. However, I question this show just because it is on MTV. Those ratings hounds there could be putting in all those nifty sound effects and such. This show would be better off and more believable on another network. Say, doesn't MTV stand for Music Television? I could be wrong.

Name: zacman
Comments:
the blair witch survivor? no...maybe the survivor witch project? that's not it either. curses!!

Name: jeff
Comments:
eMpTyV has come a long way from Devo to useless junk like this...geez, they should change their logo from a big m and a little tv to a little m and a big tv...what a waste of airwaves...

Name: Rachel
Comments:
ok shaun the show wasn't that bad. i know i would be scared out of my mind if i had to walk into an electrocution chamber in the dark!